It was all going so predictably well. Coldplay's new album went straight to No 1 on Sunday, selling 300,000 copies in three days; concerts sold out; that iTunes ad was everywhere. Even their notoriously sniffy critics in the music press seemed, with the odd exception, unusually muted.
Then, things took a sudden turn for the worse – with a plagiarism row.
Yesterday, the band was forced to issue a categorical denial of allegations
that they copied the title track to their new record, Viva La Vida Or Death
and All His Friends from a little-known US group, Creaky Boards.
In a video posted on the video-sharing website YouTube, Andrew Hoepfner,
Creaky Boards' singer and songwriter, claimed that the melody of Coldplay's
song, "Viva La Vida", is pinched from a track he wrote last year
called, ironically, "The Songs I Didn't Write".
He blamed Chris Martin for the alleged artistic theft, saying that Coldplay's
frontman attended a Creaky Boards concert in New York last year. "We
were flattered when we thought we saw Chris Martin in the crowd," said
Mr Hoepfner. "He seemed pretty into it... Maybe TOO into it?"
The clip, which was first posted on Sunday, rapidly went viral. By last night,
it had been watched by nearly 300,000 people, many thousands of whom had
typed comments remarking upon the various similarities between the two
tracks. In an industry where even small chord sequences can become subject
of costly copyright disputes, allegations of plagiarism are as potentially
damaging to a musician's finances as they are to their reputation.
Little surprise, then, that Coldplay responded with a vigorous denial. "We
totally refute their claims, and there are two facts that make it easy to
disprove them," said the band's spokesman Murray Chalmers. "First,
on the night in October when the band say Chris Martin was watching them, he
was actually working at the Air Studio in London, and we can prove that.
Second, even if he had been at the gig, "Viva la Vida" was written
and demoed seven months before the night in question, so it couldn't
possibly have been copied."
Sources close to the band said they were unlikely to pursue legal action
against Creaky Boards, since it would "look bad" to start a David
versus Goliath lawsuit against a group of young musicians. They are,
however, pushing for them to publicly withdraw the allegations of
plagiarism.
The two tracks have different lyrics, say the Coldplay camp. Although certain
elements of their melody sound remarkably similar, the band say this is due
to simple coincidence rather than a case of artistic theft.
Either way, the trite nature of Mr Hoepfner's video clip has succeeded in
gaining a new following for his band, and was driving traffic to their
MySpace page. The YouTube video concludes: "I wish Coldplay the best of
luck. If they ever want to collaborate, I've got some microphones we could
use in my bedroom."
Creaky Boards' video outlining the similiarities between the two songs
Coldplay are recording several live TV performances to promote their record in
the US, but are steering clear of major interviews, following last week's
incident on BBC Radio 4 when Martin walked out of an interview with the arts
show Front Row, saying he did not like "having to talk about things".
Rock royalty vs pop paupers
Coldplay
* Chris Martin is widely considered one of the most influential musicians of
his generation, and was acclaimed as "heir apparent to Bono" on
the band's last tour in 2006.
* Coldplay boast 447,546 friends on MySpace and 222,985 fans on Facebook.
* Coldplay are signed to Parlophone, part of EMI.
* Chris Martin is married to the actress Gwyneth Paltrow.
Creaky Boards
* Andrew Hoepfner's biggest endorsement so far comes from a New York free
paper, The Village Broadsheet: "His songs hit on a strange-but-perfect
kink-swing tradition"
* Creaky Boards have 1,873 friends on MySpace. They don't bother with
Facebook.
* Creaky Boards are still looking for a record deal.
* Andrew Hoepfner's marital status is unknown.
See Also
